A young man took his violin from the box on the floor and performed a new melody in his husky voice. Members of the audience congratulated and embraced the performer, WR Supratman, composer of what is now the national anthem, “Indonesia Raya”; security officers looked confused, and probably they were also moved,” reads a historical record of the last day of the second Youth Congress on Oct. 28, 1928 — which we now commemorate as Youth Pledge Day.

In the following months, Dutch colonial officials tried to decide what to do with the song, knowing that the flames of the then growing nationalist sentiment would easily spread if they banned it.

The song was just one product of the Congress, which became historically noted for its Youth Pledge. Youth of various organizations from Java, Maluku, Sumatra and Sulawesi, among others, pledged to become one nation, one land, with one language — Indonesian.

Despite repeated warnings that the Congress should not mention anything political and should not raise the word “independence”, the concept of “Indonesia” stuck as a main reference of an indeginous identity, other than as subjects of the Netherlands Indies, and even as most of the islanders were not speaking “Indonesian”.

In an independent Indonesia, when stability settled in, confusing questions of that indeginous identity became taken for granted, once Indonesia encompassed the sprawling archipelago from Aceh to Papua.

Then, with the end of the authoritarian New Order, things were not so settled. Years of abuse and cruelty in resource-rich lands with poor people led to stunning results — stunning to those who believed the big lie that we were all a happy family. The Timorese finally gained independence as they had long wished, and the Acehnese and the Papuans also said they wanted out.

Until today, 84 years after that congress on Jl. Kramat, Central Jakarta, things are still not so settled.

Foreign observers may not be quite surprised — there was little to unite the archipelago in the first place, apart from the former maps of the East Indies or the kingdoms of old. Regional autonomy was the genius way out of
the euphoric atmosphere that freedom brought, the
freedom to differ from the capital, which once harshly dictated uniformity. Hence, for better or for worse, every year we have new regencies or provinces — the latest being North Kalimantan, the province officially created late Monday.

Others want a national overhaul — militant jihadis have bombed their way, they believed, to heaven, to try and replace an “infidel” state, earning derision from fellow Indonesians.

So what glues us together as a nation? One clue lies in the process leading to the Youth Congress itself, the deliberations of young men and women. The Javanese were initially adamant that Javanese should be the national language, for instance, as they saw that they constituted the majority. But the need to communicate across the islands, besides the search for a similar, new identity as free subjects from colonial rule, led to the agreement and the legacy of Bahasa Indonesia.

Mutual needs, and mutual respect for differences, were also legacies of that Congress. The nation today could gain much from reviewing the historic lessons of the young people of that earlier and, it seems, wiser generation.